Sunday, February 27, 2011

HW 36 Pregnancy and Birth Stories

Interview with M.I. (Interviewee requested anonymity)(Interview was conducted in person and recorded onto a word document.  To download the word document, click the download link below.)
Three of particularly interesting, informative, and insightful elements of pregnancy/birth experience:
      1. A child is a part of his or her's mother's flesh.  A child embodies DNA, blood, and life.
      2. Having a baby is part of creating a whole family.  It gives a mother and a father a greater purpose in life.
      3. A healthy mother means a healthy baby.
Analysis
       When I interviewed M, she was very straightforward with her answers.  I wasn't sure if it was because I was relatively close with her or if she had just felt comfortable talking about birth.  Nevertheless, her demeanor was welcoming and I had no trouble asking her questions.  With birth, there comes many responsibilities, those of which M had clearly anticipated.  "I did what every mother would think to do.  I bought lots of diapers, baby clothes, and formula."  I mused at the idea of several diapers stacked up against the wall in a pastel-colored room, as I'd picture many baby rooms to be decorated in such way.  I began to wonder when it came time for me to sacrifice my vulva for my future offspring, would I be the often distraught-looking woman walking out of the store with tons of baby diapers and formula in my arms?  Surely this visual was not categorized as what made nurturing a child "absolutely wonderful."  Instead, it was the concept of a mother nurturing and raising a piece of her own "flesh, blood, and DNA."  I wondered if this idea correlated to the theory that parents choose to have kids because kids are like puppets, in which parents can vicariously live through and wish to fulfill desires that have already waned as the parent's youth has become more or less nonexistent.


Interview with J.F. (Interviewee requested anonymity)(Interview was conducted in person and recorded onto a word document.  To download the word document, click the download link below.)
DOWNLOAD LINK (CLICK HERE)
Three of particularly interesting, informative, and insightful elements of pregnancy/birth experience:
      1.  A mother's physical appearance after giving birth should be restored to the mother's prime physical state (before birth).
      2.  Birth is somewhat of an excuse to bring together a family.  The birth of a child can reconcile and rekindle an old relationship between two family members.
      3.  People are more considerate when a woman has a fetus in her womb.
Analysis
       J had wide range of facial expressions when she responded to my questions.  They were clear signals of her emotions as looks of exasperation, happiness, and fatigue ran across her face.  "I was overfilled with joy, and this continued throughout most of the 9 months I was pregnant. Of course I was scared at times, but my husband and I were so happy that that was the main emotion that controlled our lives."  Having heard this, I find its often easy to get caught up in the emotions that embody the good aspects of life and happiness and so, people believe in what will benefit them if they have a baby.  One benefit that comes from having a baby is reconnecting with family members. "My mother-in-law also made that time of my life memorable; she would take me shopping and would come over to our place once a week to chat; she was also very happy to soon be a grand mother, being as my husband is an only child."  Maybe reconciling with family members is also something parents seek when they choose to have a baby or not.  


Interview with my Mother (My mother preferred to respond to my questions in Cantonese but I will quote and translate specific portions of this interview in my analysis.  Please disregard any loud noises or sounds you may hear in the audio, other than the actual voices.)
Three of particularly interesting, informative, and insightful elements of pregnancy/birth experience:
      1.  The emotional state while carrying a baby in your womb is important in allowing the baby to enter a healthy and happy environment.
      2.  Miscarriages are never a good thing.
      3.  Pain is in a sense that is memorable during birth but, is also a joyous thing.  It means that the baby is finally entering the world.
Analysis
       Having noted that I've talked to my mother about birth already, I hadn't anticipated a couple of insights she had to offer.  My mother began talking about the physical aspects that childbearing consists of and surprisingly did not start with the emotional aspects of creating new life.  As much as I wanted our conversation to hit a climatic point where one of us would have an emotional discourse, our conversation ran smoothly and incredibly nonchalantly.  However, there were certainly subtle signs of her discomfort, "I had almost had a miscarriage.  Gladly, you held on."  I felt a pang of relief to know that my presence was regarded in such a way.  The pain and discomfort my birth had caused my mother was certainly "something never to be forgotten because of the extreme pain".  However my mother said the pain she endured was a mark forever in her mind because it was the beginning of new life, life that was somewhat of her own.  "The pain I endure during the birth meant that you were finally entering this world. It meant that I would finally be able to hold you, call you my own, and let you join my family."  Is it the pain that creates the automatic bond between the mother and child?  Is it such intense emotion that makes the waking up at the mere hours of the night to tend to the child, the persisting fatigue, and nerving back pains from carrying a child worth it?


After learning these stories, I feel inspired to explore the correlation/relationship between the amount of pain a mother feels while in labor and the significance she puts into creating the optimal life for her child.  What makes childbearing so admirable, beautiful, and rewarding? 


Thursday, February 17, 2011

HW 35 - Other Peoples' Perspectives 1

Interview with Henry Guss (Interview was conducted by virtual means and was recorded onto a word document. To download the file, click the link below.)

Interview with Lawrence Wong (Interview was conducted by virtual means and was recorded onto a word document. To download the file, click the link below.)

Interview with Alina Leuca (Interview was conducted by virtual means and was recorded onto a word document.  To download the file, click the link below.)

Interview with Evan Wood (Please disregard any background noise and to maximize the experience of listening, please raise your volume.)

       At our prime physical and mental state, we are the ripe fruits of our age.  Us adolescents have means to explore the complexes of life, including that of birth.  The cartoonish portrayals of birth, in all its gore and glory, merely dip into our conscious and subconscious thoughts of what birth actually means, consists of, and creates.  In exploring my generation's understanding of birth, I've come to find that adolescents my age have actually considered, though in a small manner, what birth can offer—the possibility of a family, the hardships childbearing may bring, the responsibility of raising a child, the physical pain birth requires, and most importantly new decisions to be made.  The majority of the people I had interviewed had openly acknowledged their lack of expertise on birth with a certain awkward distaste for talking so casually about something that was not going to be important for at least another decade.  Nevertheless, the interviews unveiled the social conventions, consideration of other's opinions, a rational mindset, and the need to satisfy a prevalent desire for a child that dominate people's concept of birth.
       The cliche genuine smiles and focused glances on the animated face of the baby evoke one message: birth and the nurturing of a child is a luxury.  We've all been told the paragons of birth and probably have succumbed to believe that we should love and desire birth because it is beautiful, natural, and rewarding.  All such stories and anecdotes are a mere cover for its nature as social convention.  "When I imagine the joy of being a parent—I know that I want as many children as possible" (Leuca).  Leuca demonstrates that her initial thoughts on birth seem to cover the jubilant aspects of childbearing and not what is gruesome, arduous, and laborious.  My generation's immediate thoughts are stemmed from people having told them that having a family, giving birth, and raising a child is social norm, which is expected for a human race to flourish.  Thus, my generation has been taught to take consideration of society's dominant opinion on birth and more or less believe the virtues of the social conventions that surround it.        
       While we all have our whimsical, even maybe aberrant, moments, we tend to be more rational when it comes to making decisions dealing with birth.  Most parents want to provide their children with the optimal life—clothes made of the finest quality, food made by the most renowned chefs, shoes crafted by hands of expertise, and even a home designed for leisure.  Though it isn't so much about the parent's desire to provide such a life but the parent's capability of doing so.  A rudimentary job will not place a bib on a baby's neck, provide a safe environment, put food on the table for a family, and essentially provide a stable life for a child.  "I myself will not have children until I can make sure I am able to support them financially and give them the best life possible" (Leuca).  The thought of having a child is eliminated if one is unable to provide sustenance.  "In my case, I would have more than one child...I wouldn't say four, I don't know, maybe it's just my mind, financially, I don't think I could handle it" (Wood).  To be aware of the financial aspect of giving birth to and raising a child is to think rationally.  Fortunately, a concern for the well-being of the child is certainly apparent in the minds of my generation.  "Children are something that should be treated kindly—nowadays they are made because they are wanted and people should treat them as such" (Guss).

Monday, February 14, 2011

HW 34 - Some Initial Thoughts On Birth

     The ideas and ideologies that surround birth are both relevant and completely foreign to me. While I am aware of where and when I was born, I will never be able to understand the mental and physical emotions my mother recalls as her most painful and excruciating moment.  Having noticed I used the word "never", my diction seems to reveal my unconscious fear of becoming a mother, or rather all that comes with becoming responsible for a child that is born from my own womb.  The path toward parenthood is unwelcoming as I picture a white-walled hospital room with a nervous father pacing about, a distressed mother grimacing as she is in labor, and anxious relatives waiting impatiently.  I'd wonder what decisions would have to be made after the umbilical cord is severed?  Who will disagree with the choices I decide to make?  Am I fit to raise a child?  I fear that a hardship my child will encounter, even at birth, will be of my doing.  Knowing that I could have prevented such misfortune would pose as the grief I may possibly cause to my child and myself.*  The idea that childbearing is reason enough to say that being a woman is more difficult than being a man is seeming less insane as I continue to collect my thoughts, memories, and associations about birth.
       Sitting down uncomfortably on the uptown 6 train, I glance over at people with headphones over their ears, reading books, staring off into space, dosing off into sleep and find myself trying to tune in on other people's conversations simply because it would be best that I not be left alone to my wandering thoughts.  The sound of two women talking boisterously about the hardships of being women, oppressed by men, did not fail to reach the canals of my ears.  "Being a woman is far more difficult than being a man.  It's us women who have to go through the pain and suffering of birth.  It is childbearing that leaves us with stretch marks beyond repair.  Men receive all the glory, and for what?  What pain have they endured?"  I thought to myself, "What ignorance would drive a woman to compare her pain from childbearing to that of a man, incapable of giving birth?"  Many women believe that there is a sense of heroism that directly correlates to their ability to give birth.  Suppose stretch marks are like battle wounds, merely existing but, never boasted about.  If many women are so concerned about receiving adulation and justice for their efforts as mothers, why do they show such shame in their "battle wounds" by seeking out all means to remove them?  It seems that I have come to a natural stopping point, however, we can really begin to focus on how our society or rather, its women, stigmatize birth and create practices to counter whatever obstacles childbearing may bring about.

*"the greatest griefs are those that we cause ourselves"- Sophocles - was an Ancient Greek dramatist, playwright, priest, and a politician of Athens. (496 BC- 406 BC).

Questions I would like to explore in this unit: 
- Why is natural birth seen as respectable?
- Why does society put a huge amount of significance on birth, so much to the extent that it creates books guiding future parents on "the right way" to raise a child?
- What is a "healthier" birth? (Hospital, at home, under-water?)
- What do stretch marks represent in the eyes of women who have already given birth and are impregnated?
- If a woman does not desire to reproduce at any point in her life, is her life considered "incomplete" because she does not muse for a child?
- What do some women regret about taking pain-numbing drugs while in labor?
- Why does society focus more on the role women play in birth than the role men play?
- Why do certain cultures eat the placenta after the birthing of a baby?
- How do we decide what is right or wrong for a child?
- How often do parents consider other parent's experiences with birth while making certain decisions?
- Is our society mocking birth with the advent of shows like 16 and Pregnant and Teen Mom?